Motivation
One critique of Akka, that comes up every now and then is the lack of type safety. Actors essentially represent a PartialFunction[Any, Unit]
which is, from a type point of view, something of the worst you can have. It tells you nothing useful; Anything can go in, it might or might not be processed and if so, anything anywhere anytime can happen. It forgoes all the benefits of a statically typed language.
There are many reasons for this though, amongst others: location transparency and context.become
. While its true that only Any
allows us to model everything that can happen, it doesn’t mean that everything will always happen. Not every actor gets moved around between different nodes and changes its behavior to something completely unrelated over and over again.
So, why not tell the compiler that we know something about certain actors and have it help us? We’re in a statically typed language after all. We’re used to compiler support when it comes to refactoring, design and composition. Why forgo this for the sake of a feature I don’t want to use.
Hence, Typed Actors
!
Akka underwent some experiments itself, for example from typed-channels and typed-actors to akka-typed.
Especially the last approach, Akka Typed
is really nice and the benefit of having an ActorRef[A]
lead to the creation of this library.
Typed Actors
has the following goals:
- add a compile-time layer to existing
ActorRef
s with minimal runtime overhead - be compatible with all of the existing Akka modules, traits, and extensions in terms of composition and behavior
and the following non-goals:
- enforce an impenetrable mantle of types, don’t fight the users knowledge about the actor system, those are dynamic after all
- support Java
So, let’s dive in.